Reviews for The generals : Patton, MacArthur, Marshall, and the winning of World War II
Library Journal
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Furnishing much more than the World War II experiences of three consequential American military commanders, notable writer Groom (Shiloh, 1862; Forrest Gump) has written an accessible, honest, largely laudatory contextualized narrative of the intertwined careers of George Patton, Douglas MacArthur, and George Marshall. The men excelled as strategists and managers of war, with Marshall successfully adapting his talents as a peace-seeking secretary of state; the European Recovery Plan (Marshall Plan) bore his name and earned him a Nobel Prize. Blunt-speaking Patton, a promoter of armored warfare, overcame dyslexia to become an avid writer of poetry. Equally swashbuckling and contradictory, MacArthur imagined that people conspired against him but often offered wise counsel. Their commonalities are striking-all had Episcopalian and at least partially Southern family backgrounds and consequential life-shaping experiences in World War I. Groom explains terms and synthesizes secondary sources such as published papers and diaries (notably of Patton). The larger-than-life personas of these legends arguably helped shape the world's view of immediate postwar America, yet so did Dwight Eisenhower, who appears here throughout all of their sagas. VERDICT There is much material on the battle tactics of both World Wars, which should appeal to military buffs, while general readers will welcome a review of the facts about these men conveyed through felicitous prose.-Frederick J. Augustyn Jr., Lib. of Congress, Washington, DC © Copyright 2015. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Interwoven biographies of three of the great American military leaders of the 20th century. Groom's (The Aviators: Eddie Rickenbacker, Jimmy Doolittle, Charles Lindbergh, and the Epic Age of Flight, 2014, etc.) three subjects are both interesting in their own rights and sufficiently contrasting personalities to keep the narrative from bogging down. Patton developed the essentials of tank warfare in World War I and went on to use them brilliantly in World War II. Marshall became typecast as a staff officer, too valuable at organizing logistics, personnel, and supply to risk in a combat command. He remains best known for the plan that led to the economic revival of Europe after the war. MacArthur was perhaps the finest field general of them all, yet like Marshall, his greatest achievement may have come when the war was over, in creating the groundwork for modern Japan. Steady, self-effacing Marshall was a team player, while the other two were ego-driven and jealous of all rivals. Groom takes each of them from youth to the ends of their careers, taking advantage of opportunities to comment on historical trends. While the author is by no means a strong stylisttoo fond of clichs, given to piling up adjectives, often clumsy on the sentence levelhe's a first-rate storyteller, and these three men give him plenty of material. He trots out the great quotes and the telling anecdotes from each of their careers and takes full advantage of their many interactions with other famous figures, such as MacArthur's discovery that Lindbergh was flying fighters in the South Pacific during the war. Groom also has a novelist's sense of timing and scene-building. His research, drawing on his subjects' own writings, effectively draws out their characters. Some readers may find his sympathy with the rather conservative politics of MacArthur and Patton off-putting, but one suspects that sympathy was a strong ingredient in his ability to paint such compelling pictures of them. Military history that reads like a novel, full of great stories and vivid scenes. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
