Reviews for Where there was fire (Book)
Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
A Costa Rican family is torn apart by multiple tragedies over several generations. One fateful night in 1968, Lyra and Carmen’s family is changed forever: Their maternal grandmother dies, and their father, José María, sets fire to the American Fruit Company, the banana plantation where he works, and then disappears. Afterward, Teresa, their distraught mother, flees to Washington, D.C., for six years with no contact, leaving the sisters in the care of their godmothers. This is the second time Teresa has faced loss related to the plantation: Her father worked there as a corporate lawyer until he too disappeared one day. Jumping forward to 1995, Lyra is estranged from her mother as she raises Carmen’s son, 10-year-old Gabriel, as her own following Carmen’s death by suicide when he was a newborn. Now working as an infertility counselor in San José, Lyra meets a patient who used to work at the American Fruit Company and who has a box of documents he was supposed to destroy. As Lyra begins to research the bad deeds of the company that fractured her family, she wrestles with whether to reconcile with her mother, newly diagnosed with cancer, and be truthful with Gabriel about his family. Arias’ debut novel seeps with spirits and omens as the devastating impact of imperialism is examined. The story is told through a kaleidoscope of moments in multiple time periods, leaving the reader to piece together knowledge alongside Lyra even as the truth will come far too late to heal the devastating wounds left behind: “Ashes cannot testify on the witness stand.” Arias ably balances the weight of a family drama with a broader depiction of Costa Rican history, though the characters could be more fully depicted and, just as for Lyra and Gabriel, not all the pieces come together for the reader. A striking debut rich in secrets and sadness. Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
