 |
by Katie Porter Kirkus Debut memoir from the whiteboard-wielding U.S. representative. Since her election to the House of Representatives in 2018, Porter has established a reputation as a no-nonsense single mother fighting on behalf of everyday people. As an Iowa native who spent her early childhood on the family farm, Porter comes by her Everywoman persona honestly. Later, she graduated from Phillips Academy, Yale, and Harvard Law School, and she counts Elena Kagan, Elizabeth Warren, and Kamala Harris among her mentors. Had Hillary Clinton won the presidency in 2020, Porter would have been on her transition team. Although the author never planned to run for office, she’s not exactly a political outsider. Maybe it’s the tension between these very different aspects of her story that makes her come across as defensive. Eschewing a chronological narrative, Porter offers a series of essays that don’t fully cohere thematically or stylistically. There are autobiographical vignettes; detailed—possibly too detailed—descriptions of her work as an academic specializing in bankruptcy law; and numerous diatribes. Some chapters are terrific. Her fiery explanation of how difficult it is to serve in Congress unless you’re independently wealthy should make us all angry, and her account of the role domestic violence has played in her life is affecting. Her description of the senior project she completed at Yale—about a dying Iowa city being “revitalized” by big agriculture—serves as a sort of intellectual and political origin story. The author seldom misses an opportunity to take a swipe at someone—her staffers and House colleagues get especially rough treatment—and the chief takeaway from her brief account of the Jan. 6 insurrection is that while she was largely unfazed, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez was distraught, hoping that the MAGA hordes wouldn’t recognize her. The only person who emerges from these pages looking good is Sen. Warren, someone for whom Porter has genuine respect and affection. Porter is a remarkable woman, but she undercuts her important accomplishments in the way she tells her story. Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission. Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission. |