Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

"It's hard for a small, ugly skeleton to make friends."Skeleton Oscar is sad when he loses a toothhe looks "so dreadful" without itbut at least he has his skeleton dog, Tag, to play with. One day, he sees a little girl burying a tooth; she seems to be a possible friend. When she sees Oscar's missing tooth, she laughs out loud and offers him the tooth she is about to bury. A moment later, she takes him by the hand, and their adventure begins. The minimal text lets the collaged pictures tell the story. Oscar and the girl look at a rainbow and smell the scent of wet grass and visit her house, where they meet her ma. They also frolic at the seaside and share their biggest secrets. Oscar takes her by the hand to return the favor. He takes her to his favorite places: the park and the library and up a tree to look for sleeping butterflies. Readers will note that the backgrounds of her world are vivid and bright while his are black with hints of brown and warm reds. Both are richly textured and fanciful, the gutter serving as permeable demarcation between worlds. At day's end, Oscar gives her back the tooth; what he's found is much more valuable.Color and composition combine to beautifully express friendship and the wonders of the world. (Picture book. 3-12) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Book list
From Booklist, Copyright © American Library Association. Used with permission.

Oscar, a lonely skeleton child, is certain that after losing a tooth he must find a replacement, otherwise no one will want to be his friend because of how frightful he looks with a gap in his mouth. When he sees a little girl burying a tooth that she has just lost, they strike a deal: she will give Oscar her tooth, and in exchange he will help her find a friend. As the pair spends time together, visiting each other's worlds, they come to realize that each has found what they are looking for. Pawlak tells his story through breathtaking paper-collage artwork that will have readers pausing to explore details large and small. Oscar is adorable, even as a skeleton, depicted in red shorts, with rosy cheeks and expressive eyebrows. His world, drab and gray with its dark skies, creeping vines, and skeletons, nonetheless has an enchanting glow, equal to his friend's luminescent world of oceans and rainbows, both emitting comfort and happiness. When text is used, it is large, clear, and efficient, often speaking volumes with wordless spreads. Through this careful storytelling, readers will come to know the wishes and dreams of Oscar and his new friend. A magical story that feels like a fairytale, depicting the beauty of friendship.--Selenia Paz Copyright 2010 Booklist

Publishers Weekly
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved

Oscar the skeleton is missing a tooth, and he’s cruelly self-conscious about his looks and prospects (“It’s hard for a small, ugly skeleton to make friends”). A pigtail-wearing human girl who’s burying a tooth to help her dream come true offers it to Oscar if he’ll help her find a friend. She shows him the beautiful places in her world (“She said she’d like to take her friend to a meadow and show them a rainbow”), and he reciprocates, bringing her to a dreamy flower-filled underworld of skeletons who ride velocipedes and browse library shelves. Pawlak’s paper collage characters fairly jump from the page, with expressive, engaging eyes and details worth returning to. Though the girl never indicates that Oscar is the friend she’s wished for, she promises to return, and Oscar gives the tooth back, having found that a new smile wasn’t needed for friendship or self-worth, after all. Ages 5–8. (Oct.)