Library Journal
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Tony-nominated Broadway star Megan Hilty proves to be an ideal narrator, effortlessly assuming (almost-)always-in-control Dannie and her free-spirited best friend, Bella. In the evening after a near-perfect day—accepting the perfectly orchestrated marriage proposal after wowing her interviewers for her ideal job—Dannie falls into an exhausted sleep. She's startled awake five years into the future in a bed, an apartment, and with a man she absolutely doesn't recognize but most definitely can't resist. And then she wakes up for real this time, back in her own home with her familiar fiancé. Disturbed but determined, Dannie makes sure life continues according to plan, until four years later, that dreamy stranger reappears: he's Bella's new lover (finally, a real keeper this time) and he's renovating that same loft. Can Dannie escape a future that shouldn't possibly be hers? With affecting nuance and gentle empathy, Hilty is crisply convincing as Dannie, softly breathy as Bella. The BFFs' interactions are especially resonating, from gleeful to joyous, disappointed and dismissive, desperate and forgiving. VERDICT Hilty undoubtedly delivers a memorable aural enhancement to best-selling Serle's latest rom-com-with-a-twist.—Terry Hong, Smithsonian BookDragon, Washington, DC

Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

After acing a job interview and accepting a marriage proposal, Dannie Kohan has had the perfect day. That is, until she awakens to find herself five years in the future with a completely different man.Just one hour in that alternate reality shakes Dannie to her core. After all, highly ambitious Dannie and her boyfriend, David, have plotted out their lives in minute detail, and the sexy man in her dreamwas it a dream?is most certainly not in the script. Serle (The Dinner List, 2018) deftly spins these magical threads into Dannie's perfectly structured life, leaving not only Dannie, but also the reader wondering whether Dannie time traveled or hallucinated. Her best friend, Bella, would delight in the story given that she thinks Dannie is much too straight-laced, and some spicy dreaming might push Dannie to find someone more passionate than David. Unfortunately, glamorous Bella is in Europe with her latest lover. Ever pragmatic, Dannie consults her therapist, who almost concurs that it was likely a dream, and throws herself into her work. Pleased to have landed the job at a prestigious law firm, Dannie easily loses her worries in litigation. Soon four and a half years have passed with no wedding date set, and Bella is back in the U.S. with a new man in her life. A man who turns out to be literally the man of Dannie's dream. The sheer fact of Aaron Gregory's existence forces Dannie to reevaluate her trust in the laws of physics as well as her decision to marry David, a decision that seems less believable with each passing day. And as the architecture of Dannie's overplanned life disintegrates, Serle twists and twines the remnants of her dream into a surprising future.A heartwarming portrait of a broken heart finding a little healing magic. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Library Journal
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

A YA author and television writer whose adult debut, The Dinner List, was a LibraryReads pick, Searle introduces us to hard-charging lawyer Dannie Cohan, who's just accepted a new job and her boyfriend's proposal. That night, she's hardly dwelling on the standard interview question—where she wants to be in five years. But she goes to bed in 2020 and awakens in 2025 with a different man in a different apartment, then jolts back to her old life and wonders what is happening. With a 200,000-copy first printing.

Library Journal
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Searle's second novel (The Dinner List) ponders the question: Where do you see yourself in five years? Dannie Kohan is a corporate lawyer with an orderly life. She knows the right time to focus on work, get engaged, or buy a condo. But one night she wakes up five years into the future, glimpsing a life completely altered. She meets the man in her vision four years later—he's her best friend's boyfriend—and desperately tries to shift the trajectory of what she thinks is about to happen. But the author throws in a big twist: The story is about life, love, friendship, fate, and free will, and what Dannie experienced five years earlier isn't as clear as she'd thought. The turmoil of Dannie's love life and, more important, her friendship with best friend Bella, shape this tale of a driven, logical woman faced with emotions she's never felt before. VERDICT The story has a strong New York setting and sympathetic characters. Emotional hooks alongside moments of humor and self-awareness will remind readers of Jojo Moyes's Me Before You or Taylor Jenkins Reid's Maybe in Another Life. [See Prepub Alert, 9/16/19.]—Melanie Kindrachuk, Stratford P.L., Ont.

Book list
From Booklist, Copyright © American Library Association. Used with permission.

Dannie has her entire life planned out always has. So when she's asked about where she sees herself in five years during a big interview at a New York law firm, she knows exactly what to say: she'll be a senior associate at the firm, and she'll be married to her boyfriend (who does, indeed, propose that very night). And, then, after returning from her engagement dinner, Dannie has an experience that flips her carefully laid plan on its head: she spends an hour in her life five years in the future. And in that life, she's in a different apartment and with a different man. Rocked by her experience, Dannie spends the next four and a half years trying her best to stick to the plan, until the moment when the man she saw in her future appears in her life, courtesy of her best friend. Serle takes a fairly generic rom-com setup and turns it into something much deeper in this captivating exploration of friendship, loss, and love.--Bridget Thoreson Copyright 2020 Booklist

Publishers Weekly
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved

Serle’s bewitching story of love and friendship (after The Dinner List) centers on a young woman who plans her life down to the minute until fate gets in the way. At 28, Dannie Kohan lives happily with her boyfriend, David, in a Manhattan apartment and is poised to land her dream job as a lawyer at a top firm. Dannie expects to get married by the time she’s 30; right on track, David proposes, giving Dannie a ring picked out by her best friend Bella. After accepting the proposal, Dannie slips into a deep sleep and dreams of an alternate future, where everything is off-kilter. In her dream, it’s the year 2025 and she lives with a man named Aaron Gregory. Upon waking, Dannie begins to second-guess her regimented course, and as the years pass, she puts off the marriage. On a rainy day in June 2025, she meets up with Bella, now a successful art dealer, and is stunned to find her accompanied by Aaron, the man from her dream. She senses a mutual recognition, and, after Bella receives devastating news, Dannie and Aaron grow closer. While the plot hinges on well-worn tropes, the deadpan prose highlights the author’s keen sense of irony. Serle’s whimsical tale is book club catnip. (Mar.)This review has been updated to remove a spoiler.